Fallujah: The Hidden Massacre
Special screening in Rome
November 30, 2005
The atrocity of war is such that it might seem misplaced to get worked up about the use in Iraq of the chemical agent White Phosphorous – now officially confirmed by the Pentagon after the RAI News24 scoop last month made further denial impossible. [see the video]
In fact, the very RAI video screened last Wednesday (November 30th) at the Linux Club revealed to the USC4P&J members present, and to the large Italian crowd in the main room, not only the chemical horrors being committed by allied troops in Iraq, but also conventional horrors that dwarf the sadly famous scenes of the massacre of civilians in Vietnam, which the RAI video recalled at the beginning.
Yes, the pictures of Falluja civilians scorched to death in their beds by phosphorous mist, with their bedclothes still intact, were shocking. But the video then went on to show us other scenes from Iraq we would never have wished to see: for example, the corpses of tortured Iraqi prisoners, their bodies punctured with dozens of holes made by some maniac interrogator wielding an electric drill. Somehow the horror of the high tech deaths inflicted by refined phosphorous mists paled before the horror of the low tech deaths inflicted by a Black and Decker.
Thus, Sigfrido Ranucci and Maurizio Torrealta's implacable report, "La strage nascosta" ("The Hidden Massacre"), was in a certain sense counterproductive. "White phosphorous?" a cynic might ask (and one of the Italians present -- Stefano -- did); "so what? Is a 'Shake and Bake death' in your bed by white phosphorous any worse than a 'Black and Decker death' in a jail cell? When a nation accepts war, there are no longer any limits, high or low tech. Let's not waste time decrying this or that weapon. The only fight worth fighting is to put an end to war."
And yet I feel the screening of the RAI film served a purpose -- and is continuing to do so (the request for local screenings is keeping the authors booked until fall of 2007). The indiscriminate character of the mass killing produced by the phosphorous spewed over Eastern Fallujah, which satellite pictures showed us as an immense black splotch on the map, sets off an alarm inside the conscience of any but the most jaded observer. While nothing excuses the low tech horror of guerrilla beheadings or allied sexual abuses in the Abu Grahib prison, there are nonetheless limits.
Public opinion must rise up united to stop the use of arms that wipe out whole neighborhoods and entire towns, whether they be called Falluja (phosphorous mist), Hiroshima (atomic bomb), Dresda (napalm and phosphorous), or Guernica (fire bombs and blockbusters). Yes, the real fight is to stop war, not the use of this or that weapon. But in the meantime we must put a limit to the escalating production of ever more insidious weapons of mass destruction.
The public at the Linux screening, riveted to their seats during the 30 minute video, may have been thinking just that: something was touching their sense of inner revolt. Then the film ended, the speakers assembled on the stage and there was a long silence. Not many of the Americans remained for the entire debate, whether shocked by the scenes they had just witnessed or simply tired (the screening started an hour and a half late).
The Italians stayed on and let the first two speakers (a Senator and a City Councilman) give their talks, then erupted with vehemence. "War crimes" was the most common expression used.
The moderator finally reined them in and permitted the other guests on the stage to have their say, among whom the newly elected chair of USC4P&J, Stephanie Westbrook, who informed the public of how the Falluja story broke in U.S. media. The first headlines were for a Reuters story picked up by many news outlets and all began with "US Denies" or "Pentagon Denies" or "Military Denies Use of Phosphorous in Fallujah".
Peter Popham of The Independent called the Falluja massacre a turning
point in the war. Not a military one, as U.S. commanders claimed, but
rather a turning point in public opinion over just how rotten this war had
become. It was supposedly launched to liberate the Iraqis from the
horrors of Saddam Hussein, who tortured dissenters sadistically at the Abu
Ghraib prison and who used white phosphorous to annihilate Kurdish rebels
in the North. Now American troops are doing the same things to the
Iraqis.
Fabio Marcelli, of the Italian group "Democratic Magistrates", disproved the legal basis of the Pentagon claim that the use of phosphorous was permitted as a conventional weapon.
Sigfrido Ranucci, one of the video's producers, gave the thirty or so participants who held out until 11 p.m. a series of fascinating behind-the-scenes views of how scoops are muffled by mainstream media -- and not only with respect to "The Hidden Massacre".
It was an extremely informative evening, made possible by the generosity and hard work of the Linux Club staff and, for the USC4P&J members present, by the volunteer interpreting done by Traduttori per la pace (Translators for Peace). A big thanks to both.
The atrocity of war is such that it might seem misplaced to get worked up about the use in Iraq of the chemical agent White Phosphorous – now officially confirmed by the Pentagon after the RAI News24 scoop last month made further denial impossible. [see the 
